The Budget Amendments Review Subcommittee (BARSC) amendments of 1–2 October 2026, checked against the FY 2027 General Appropriations Bill (GAB) as the House printed it (HB 10858, Volumes I-A and I-B). Prepared 8 October 2026.
Summary
The House bill keeps the NEP total, so every BARSC peso was paid for with a cut. New appropriations total ₱4,494.08B in both the NEP and HB 10858. The ₱116.32B the BARSC added is offset by ₱116.32B in cuts. [1][2]
The hearing showed only the additions. The cuts are printed in the bill, but none was read out at the hearing. ₱85.43B of them fall inside the same agencies that received additions. Another ₱30.89B come from agencies and funds the BARSC never took up. [2][3]
That is why a NEP-to-GAB comparison shows only ₱82.4B moving. An agency-level comparison nets each agency's additions against its own cuts. DepEd received ₱1.95B in BARSC additions but ends ₱6.17B lower, so it shows up as a cut. [2]
Ten sources supplied ₱108.09B, 93% of the money. The largest is ₱42.80B from four DOTr rail, transport and port projects, ₱35.1B of it in loan proceeds. [2][6]
The cuts reach programs the hearing said it was raising. The BARSC added ₱1.55B to the Health Facilities Enhancement Program (HFEP). In the bill, HFEP ends ₱4.45B below the NEP. [1][6]
They also reach health, school and disaster lines the hearing never discussed. The bill halves DOH's commodities for family health, immunization and nutrition, halves the terminal-leave and retirement-gratuity funds for retiring workers, and halves the Calamity Fund's rehabilitation aid to LGUs. [6]
23 of the 33 BARSC agency groups appear in the bill exactly as approved. This includes DPWH (₱11.49B), CHED, TESDA, the LGSF, the House (₱5B) and all eight SUCs. AICS and MAIFIP each landed exactly ₱1B below what the BARSC approved. [1][2]
1. Every peso added was cut somewhere else
₱
Added by the BARSC
+116,317,059,750
Cut from the same agencies that received additions
−85,426,857,750
Cut from agencies and funds the BARSC did not take up
−30,890,202,000
Change in total new appropriations
0
Most of the money came from the same agencies that received additions. DOTr, for example, received ₱2.35B for transport subsidies and local projects but lost ₱42.8B in foreign-assisted projects. DOH received ₱28.36B, mostly for MAIFIP, but its other programs lost ₱16.14B. [1][2]
The rest came from agencies and funds that never came up at the hearing. The largest are the Pension and Gratuity Fund (₱10B), the Calamity Fund (₱9.5B) and DICT (₱4.17B). [2]
The additions
The 33 agency groups the BARSC approved, largest first. Amounts are in pesos and match the hearing record. [1]
Agency group
Added (₱)
Share
Department of Health
28,364,776,000
24.39%
Department of Social Welfare and Development
26,860,300,000
23.09%
Department of Agriculture
16,440,224,000
14.13%
Department of Public Works and Highways
11,490,000,000
9.88%
Department of Labor and Employment
5,113,000,000
4.40%
House of Representatives
5,000,000,000
4.30%
National Irrigation Administration
4,092,500,000
3.52%
Local Government Support Fund
4,091,400,000
3.52%
Commission on Higher Education
3,868,865,000
3.33%
Department of Transportation
2,349,000,000
2.02%
Department of Education
1,952,000,000
1.68%
Technical Education and Skills Development Authority
1,435,910,000
1.23%
Presidential Communications Office and attached agencies
672,985,750
0.58%
Department of Human Settlements and Urban Development
595,178,000
0.51%
Department of National Defense
553,765,000
0.48%
State universities and colleges
506,000,000
0.44%
Department of the Interior and Local Government
478,000,000
0.41%
University of the Philippines System
360,000,000
0.31%
Department of Agrarian Reform
331,000,000
0.28%
Department of Migrant Workers and Overseas Workers Welfare Administration (OWA)
250,000,000
0.21%
Department of Environment and Natural Resources
209,906,000
0.18%
Commission on Audit
200,000,000
0.17%
Office of the Ombudsman
200,000,000
0.17%
Sandiganbayan (anti-graft court)
180,000,000
0.15%
Department of Justice
132,050,000
0.11%
National Anti-Poverty Commission
100,000,000
0.09%
Local Water Utilities Administration
100,000,000
0.09%
Cultural Center of the Philippines
100,000,000
0.09%
Development Academy of the Philippines
82,500,000
0.07%
Department of Trade and Industry
80,000,000
0.07%
Energy Regulatory Commission
75,000,000
0.06%
Department of Foreign Affairs
37,500,000
0.03%
Department of Tourism
15,200,000
0.01%
Total (33 agency groups)
116,317,059,750
100%
Section 2 names the cuts that paid for these.
2. The cuts: where the money came from
Source of the cut
₱B
Inside a BARSC agency?
Department of Transportation (DOTr), foreign-assisted projects
42.80
yes (DOTr got +₱2.35B)
Department of Health (DOH), other programs
16.14
yes (DOH got +₱28.36B)
Pension and Gratuity Fund (PGF)
10.00
no
National Disaster Risk Reduction and Management Fund (Calamity Fund)
9.50
no
Department of Education (DepEd)
8.12
yes (DepEd got +₱1.95B)
National Irrigation Administration (NIA)
5.28
yes (NIA got +₱4.09B)
Department of Social Welfare and Development (DSWD), mostly foreign-assisted projects
4.79
yes
Department of Agriculture (DA) and BFAR, mostly foreign-assisted projects
4.79
yes
Department of Information and Communications Technology (DICT)
4.17
no
Philippine Reclamation Authority (PRA)
2.50
no
Department of Foreign Affairs (DFA), Consular/Assistance-to-Nationals (ATN) Program
2.00
yes (DFA got +₱37.5M)
Civil Service Commission (CSC), foreign-assisted projects
1.12
no
Philippine Statistics Authority (PSA)
1.00
no
Bases Conversion and Development Authority (BCDA)
0.84
no
Department of Tourism (DOT), Office of the Secretary
0.75
no
Department of Agrarian Reform (DAR), foreign-assisted projects
0.60
yes
Department of Human Settlements and Urban Development (DHSUD), Office of the Secretary
0.60
no
Department of Environment and Natural Resources (DENR), forest and watershed management
0.55
yes
Department of Labor and Employment (DOLE)
0.36
yes
Bureau of Internal Revenue (BIR)
0.35
no
Department of the Interior and Local Government (DILG), Office of the Secretary
0.06
no
Total
116.32
Department of Science and Technology (DOST) research councils and institutes lost ₱540M, and the DOST Office of the Secretary and the Advanced Science and Technology Institute (ASTI) gained the same amount. The department's total is unchanged, and the BARSC did not take this up. [2]
Foreign-assisted projects took half. Cuts to foreign-assisted projects at DOTr, DSWD, DepEd, DICT, DA, CSC, DOH, BFAR and DAR come to ₱57.70B, or 49.6% of the total. The bill does not say whether these cuts delay projects or only trim amounts the agencies could not spend in 2027. [2]
Our "Funds Congress Cuts" pattern is borne out in part. That analysis found ₱1.42T cut from the Miscellaneous Personnel Benefits Fund (MPBF), the PGF and DOTr foreign-assisted projects in 2016–2026. In 2027 the PGF (₱10B) and DOTr foreign-assisted projects (₱42.8B) were cut again. The MPBF was not: it stays at ₱55.87B. [4]
This fits what was said at the hearing. The money was to come from "slow moving" items with low absorptive capacity and low utilization, though no item was named. [3]
3. The ten largest sources, line by line
For each line, the cut is measured from what the line would hold if the BARSC addition were simply added to the NEP. Where the BARSC added nothing, that is the NEP amount. Each table adds up to the agency's total in section 2. [2][6]
DOTr: ₱42.80B, from four projects
The ₱2.35B the BARSC added for local projects is in the bill in full; it includes ₱774M for three airports: Central Mindanao (₱600M), Borongan (₱100M) and the Dr. Jose Rizal airstrip (₱74M). Every peso of the cut comes from four foreign-assisted projects.
Project
NEP
House bill
Cut
Metro Manila Subway Project, Phase I (JICA loans)
67.44B
47.74B
19.70B
North-South Commuter Railway (ADB and JICA loans)
123.84B
108.84B
15.00B
Davao Public Transport Modernization Project (ADB loans)
15.08B
9.98B
5.10B
New Cebu International Container Port (Korea EDCF loan)
8.99B
5.99B
3.00B
Total
42.80B
Most of the cut is borrowed money.₱35.1B comes out of loan proceeds and ₱7.7B out of the government's counterpart: ₱4.7B for the Subway and ₱3.0B for the Cebu port.
Pages: NEP Vol. III, PDF pp. 312–313; GAB Vol. I-B, PDF pp. 287–290.
DOH: ₱16.14B, led by health facilities and commodities
Line
NEP
NEP + BARSC
House bill
Cut
Health Facilities Enhancement Program (HFEP)
14.54B
16.09B
10.09B
6.00B
Commodities for family health, immunization, nutrition and responsible parenting
9.10B
9.10B
4.23B
4.87B
Health Promotion
2.54B
2.54B
0.49B
2.05B
MAIFIP
24.24B
49.20B
48.20B
1.00B
Philippines Health System Resilience Project (World Bank loan)
7.73B
7.73B
6.73B
1.00B
Quick Response Fund
0.50B
0.50B
0.10B
0.40B
Six smaller lines
0.82B
Total
16.14B
HFEP ends ₱4.45B below the NEP, even though the BARSC added ₱1.55B to it. HFEP funds the construction, upgrading and equipping of government health facilities, from DOH hospitals to primary care facilities. The bill prints it as one line, so the split between building, equipment and vehicles is not shown.
The commodities line is more than halved. It buys vaccines and nutrition supplies.
Health Promotion loses 81% and the Quick Response Fund 80%.
The six smaller lines: international health policy (₱167M), health workforce development (₱150M), health emergency preparedness (₱150M), commodities for environmental and occupational health (₱150M), commodities for family planning (₱150M) and health sector governance (₱50M).
Pages: NEP Vol. II-A, PDF pp. 247–303; GAB Vol. I-A, PDF pp. 1038–1082.
Pension and Gratuity Fund: ₱10.00B, from retirement benefits
Item
NEP
House bill
Cut
Terminal leave, military and uniformed personnel
7.42B
3.42B
4.00B
Retirement gratuity, military and uniformed personnel
6.26B
3.26B
3.00B
Terminal leave, civilian personnel
5.11B
2.61B
2.50B
Retirement gratuity, civilian personnel
3.24B
2.74B
0.50B
Total
10.00B
Pensions are untouched. Military and uniformed ₱142.95B, veterans ₱11.26B and civilian ₱2.09B are the same as in the NEP.
Only the lump sums owed to workers who retire or leave in 2027 are cut. These are the terminal-leave and retirement-gratuity lines. The NEP had roughly doubled them from 2026; the bill brings them back to about their 2026 levels.
Pages: NEP Vol. III, PDF pp. 955–962; GAB Vol. I-B, PDF pp. 609–611.
Calamity Fund: ₱9.50B, mostly from rebuilding aid to LGUs
Purpose
NEP
House bill
Cut
Disaster rehabilitation and reconstruction assistance to LGUs
14.67B
6.92B
7.75B
Disaster risk reduction, mitigation, prevention and preparedness
30.00B
28.25B
1.75B
People's Survival Fund (climate adaptation)
1.00B
1.00B
0
Total
45.67B
36.17B
9.50B
Aid to help LGUs rebuild after disasters falls by more than half.
The ₱1.75B cut to preparedness is a realignment the BARSC approved. It raised DSWD's Quick Response Fund from ₱1.25B to ₱3B with money moved from this fund (03:01:23▶). Because it moves money rather than adding it, it is not in the ₱116.32B. The other ₱7.75B was never mentioned at the hearing. [1]
Pages: NEP Vol. III, PDF pp. 937–941; GAB Vol. I-B, PDF pp. 605–608.
DepEd: ₱8.12B, from classrooms and computers
Line
NEP
NEP + BARSC
House bill
Cut
Basic Education Facilities (classrooms)
30.55B
31.50B
27.45B
4.05B
Computerization Program
5.79B
5.79B
2.63B
3.16B
Project for Learning Upgrade Support and Decentralization (PLUS-D, World Bank loan)
10.81B
10.81B
9.41B
1.40B
Infrastructure for Safer and Resilient Schools (World Bank loan)
2.16B
2.16B
1.22B
0.94B
In-service training for teachers and school personnel
3.01B
3.01B
2.51B
0.50B
Less: Government Assistance and Subsidies (private-school vouchers), increased
38.12B
38.12B
40.05B
−1.93B
Net
8.12B
Classrooms end ₱3.10B below the NEP. The BARSC added ₱952M for them.
The Computerization Program loses 55%.
The ₱1.93B the BARSC did not approve goes to private-school subsidies. Government Assistance and Subsidies funds the Educational Service Contracting, Senior High School Voucher and Joint Delivery Voucher programs.
Pages: NEP Vol. I, PDF pp. 367–624; GAB Vol. I-A, PDF pp. 270–459.
NIA: ₱5.28B, from named irrigation projects
Line
NEP
NEP + BARSC
House bill
Cut
Other Irrigation Systems (restoration)
3.00B
3.06B
0.46B
2.60B
Five national irrigation projects (below)
1.95B
Six small reservoir projects (below)
0.94B
Pump irrigation (EPIP)
7.92B
9.09B
8.47B
0.62B
National Irrigation Systems
4.66B
5.97B
5.47B
0.50B
Feasibility studies (₱100M) and Special Irrigation (₱42M)
0.14B
Less: Communal Irrigation Systems, increased
1.62B
1.77B
3.24B
−1.48B
Net
5.28B
National irrigation projects cut:
Tumauini River, Isabela: ₱1.0B
Lower Apayao River, Apayao: ₱400M
Sta. Filomena, Cagayan: ₱250M
Libang River, Agusan del Sur: ₱200M, dropped entirely
Pantingan, Bataan: ₱100M short of the BARSC amount (₱500M against ₱600M)
The BARSC's ₱1B for "locally funded projects" appears as two new Isabela dams. Alimit Dam (₱500M) and Ilaguen Multipurpose Irrigation and Hydropower (₱500M) are new lines in the bill, inside the same sub-program that lost ₱1.95B.
Pages: NEP Vol. III, PDF pp. 847–854; GAB Vol. I-B, PDF pp. 567–571.
DSWD: ₱4.79B, from a community-resilience loan
Line
NEP
NEP + BARSC
House bill
Cut
Panahon ng Pagkilos: Philippine Community Resilience Project (World Bank loan)
17.66B
17.66B
12.12B
5.54B
AICS
33.28B
59.09B
58.09B
1.00B
Less: Quick Response Fund, raised by a BARSC-approved realignment from the Calamity Fund
1.25B
1.25B
3.00B
−1.75B
Net
4.79B
The Quick Response Fund increase was approved at the hearing (03:01:23▶). It is shown here because it is not among the ₱116.32B in additions: the money came from the Calamity Fund.
The resilience-project cut is all loan proceeds. Loan proceeds fall from ₱13.54B to ₱8.00B.
The other BARSC items are in the bill to the peso: the Sustainable Livelihood Program, ProtecTEEN, ARUGA, SAFE, the LGBTQIA+ committee and the Bukidnon center.
Pages: NEP Vol. III, PDF pp. 134–158; GAB Vol. I-B, PDF pp. 178–195.
DA and BFAR: ₱4.79B
Line
NEP
NEP + BARSC
House bill
Cut
Philippine Rural Development Project Scale-Up (World Bank loan)
8.86B
8.86B
7.37B
1.49B
Farm-to-market roads
16.14B
21.10B
19.81B
1.29B
Establishment of Agricultural Food Hub Project
1.50B
1.50B
0.50B
1.00B
BFAR: Philippine Fisheries and Coastal Resiliency Project (World Bank loan)
1.80B
1.80B
1.10B
0.70B
Mindanao Inclusive Agriculture Development Project (World Bank loan)
1.51B
1.51B
1.21B
0.30B
Total
4.79B
The other DA items are in the bill as approved: the ₱10B PAFFF, fertilizer, solar pumps, the cable car, ube and the BFAR ice plants.
Pages: NEP Vol. I, PDF pp. 119–213; GAB Vol. I-A, PDF pp. 87–175.
DICT: ₱4.17B, from digital infrastructure
Line
NEP
House bill
Cut
Philippine Digital Infrastructure Project (World Bank loan)
2.16B
0.36B
1.80B
National Broadband Program
1.13B
0.26B
0.87B
National Government Data Center Infrastructure
0.95B
0.20B
0.75B
Digital Government Development and Management
1.39B
0.64B
0.75B
Total
4.17B
Pages: NEP Vol. II-A, PDF pp. 344–354; GAB Vol. I-A, PDF pp. 1107–1111.
PRA: ₱2.50B, from one project
The Philippine International Exhibition Center is halved, from ₱5.0B to ₱2.5B. It is PRA's only appropriation.
Pages: NEP Vol. III, PDF pp. 862–864; GAB Vol. I-B, PDF p. 574.
4. Where the bill matches the record
Twenty-three agency groups appear in the bill to the thousand pesos. For these, the agency's total in the bill rises by exactly the BARSC amount: [1][2]
CHED ₱3.87B, TESDA ₱1.44B, the UP System ₱360M
The eight SUCs: Eastern Samar State University ₱150M, University of Southeastern Philippines ₱100M, Davao de Oro State College ₱100M, Camiguin Polytechnic ₱50M, Caraga State University ₱50M, Rizal Technological University ₱30M, Bicol University ₱20M and Isabela State University ₱6M, totalling ₱506M
DPWH ₱11.49B, LGSF ₱4.09B (to ₱62.62B), House of Representatives ₱5B
PCO and its attached agencies, including PTV-4 (₱600M) and IBC-13 (₱36.0M)
DILG's attached agencies: PNP, BFP and NAPOLCOM
DOJ, including the NBI and the Office of the Solicitor General
Department of National Defense (DND), Department of Migrant Workers (DMW), DTI's two agencies, DHSUD's NHA and SHFC, COA, the Ombudsman, the Sandiganbayan, ERC, NAPC, LWUA, CCP, DAP, and DOT's Philippine Commission on Sports Scuba Diving
The DND items withheld at the hearing can be placed by unit. The ₱553.77M whose descriptions were withheld for national security splits exactly three ways in the bill: [2][3]
Government Arsenal: ₱345.0M
Philippine Army: ₱193.77M
AFP General Headquarters and AFP-Wide Service Support Units: ₱15.0M
5. Where the bill departs from the record
In ten agency groups the bill differs from what the BARSC approved. Section 3 has the line detail for all of them except DFA, DAR, DENR and DOLE. [1][2][6]
Agency
BARSC added
Net change in the bill
Difference
DepEd
+1.95B
−6.17B
−8.12B
DOH
+28.36B
+12.23B
−16.14B
DSWD
+26.86B
+22.07B
−4.79B
DA (with BFAR and PFDA)
+16.44B
+11.65B
−4.79B
NIA
+4.09B
−1.18B
−5.28B
DOTr
+2.35B
−40.45B
−42.80B
DFA
+37.5M
−1.96B
−2.00B
DAR
+331M
−269M
−600M
DENR
+210M
−340M
−550M
DOLE
+5.11B
+4.75B
−363M
BARSC items that landed below the approved amount:
HFEP: the BARSC added ₱1.55B; the bill ends ₱4.45B below the NEP.
MAIFIP and AICS: each ₱1B short.
Farm-to-market roads: ₱1.29B short.
DepEd classrooms: the BARSC added ₱952M; the bill ends ₱3.10B below the NEP.
Pantingan reservoir: ₱100M short.
DOLE's Workers Protection and Welfare Program, which carries TUPAD and DILEEP: ₱363M short.
Additions the BARSC never approved:
DepEd private-school vouchers: ₱1.93B
NIA Communal Irrigation Systems: ₱1.48B above the BARSC's ₱147M
Cuts the hearing never mentioned, in agencies that also received additions:
DOTr: foreign-assisted projects, −₱42.8B
DFA: Consular/ATN Program, −₱2B
DAR: foreign-assisted projects, −₱600M
DENR: forest and watershed management, −₱550M
6. What this changes in our earlier analysis
"Only one side of the ledger was shown" still holds for the hearing. It no longer holds for the bill. The offsets are now identified: ₱116.32B, listed in sections 2 and 3. [5]
The seven core programs end lower than the analysis assumed. On the bill's lines:
HFEP is ₱10.09B, not ₱16.09B.
Farm-to-market roads are ₱19.63B, not ₱20.96B.
MAIFIP and AICS are each ₱1B lower.
Together the seven fall from ₱841.71B to about ₱832.38B, or 49.1% of the programmed deficit. That is still up from 45.1% in the NEP. DPWH capital outlay and TUPAD were not checked at line level. [5]
"MAIFIP received 16 times what HFEP did" understates the gap. In the bill, HFEP falls by ₱4.45B while MAIFIP rises by ₱23.97B. [5]
The pork-type programs were paid for partly by cutting services. The cuts fall on health facilities, vaccines and nutrition supplies, classrooms and school computers, irrigation projects, rebuilding aid to LGUs and retiring workers' benefits.
Method and caveats
BARSC side. We used the 33 agency groups and their line items in build_pork_page.py. They sum to ₱116,317,059,750 and match the hearing notes to the peso. [1]
Realignments. The BARSC also approved one realignment with no new money: ₱1.75B from the Calamity Fund to DSWD's Quick Response Fund (03:01:23▶). As in the hearing notes, it is not counted in the ₱116.32B. In the tables it appears as a cut to the Calamity Fund and an increase inside DSWD, which cancel out.
Matching. Each BARSC agency group is paired with the House-bill agencies it covers. The DA group, for instance, covers the DA Office of the Secretary, the Bureau of Fisheries and Aquatic Resources (BFAR) and the Philippine Fisheries Development Authority (PFDA).
House-bill side. The comparison of the NEP with HB 10858 was built on 7 October 2026 in the separate "Budget 2027 OCR" repo, at agency, cost-structure, program, sub-program and project-total level. Its House-bill figures are read directly from the born-digital PDFs of Volumes I-A and I-B. They add up to the bill's printed totals for all 369 agencies, and to its printed grand total. [2]
NEP side. The NEP volumes are scans with a text layer from optical character recognition (OCR). Amounts are reliable: 331 of 358 agencies add up to their own totals, and the NEP grand total matches Annex B within ₱200,000. That gap is a single misread: the text layer reads COMELEC's ₱29,161,661K as ₱29,161,861K. We use the printed figure, so the totals net to zero. Labels are often garbled. Where an agency's NEP figures do not add up to its total (marked NEP_FOOTS=no), as for DSWD, DPWH and PRA, check the line against the page before quoting it. [2]
Line detail (section 3). The activity and project lines for the ten largest sources were read from the extracted text of both documents, at the pages given under each table. Each source's lines add up to its offset in section 2. [6]
HFEP's NEP figure. The NEP line prints ₱14,539,832,000. The hearing read ₱14,472,659,000. The analysis uses ₱14.54B, as here.
Rounding. The bill prints amounts in thousands of pesos. The IBC-13 item (₱35,985,750) appears as ₱35,986K, a ₱250 rounding difference.
DPWH. The total matches the BARSC's ₱11.49B exactly. The program-level comparison for DPWH is unreliable, because the NEP's DPWH program lines were not fully captured. It is not used here.
Status. HB 10858 is the House's version. The Senate and the bicameral conference can still change it.
Reproducing. Run python reconcile_gab.py [path to nep_vs_gab_2027_programmes.csv]. It writes BARSC-2027-GAB-Reconciliation.csv, with one row per agency group plus every agency changed outside the record. It also writes BARSC-2027-GAB-Reconciliation-Programmes.csv, which lists every changed program line with its NEP and GAB page.
[2] HB 10858, FY 2027 GAB, Volumes I-A and I-B, and the FY 2027 NEP, Volumes I to III, as compared in "Budget 2027 OCR", Comparison/nep_vs_gab_2027_programmes.csv (built 7 October 2026). Page references for every line are in BARSC-2027-GAB-Reconciliation-Programmes.csv.
[3] Hearing transcript, 00:09:15–00:10:13 (SDS Hernandez on "slow moving" items) and 00:18:56–00:21:08 (the Chair on fiscal space); DND items at the DND section of the notes.
[4] DSWD folder, Funds Congress Cuts.html (15 September 2026).
[5] BARSC-2027-Amendments-Analysis.md (5 October 2026), §1, §3, §4 and §7.
[6] The same documents' extracted text in "Budget 2027 OCR", out/NEP-2027-VOLUME-*/ and out/HGAB-2027-VOL-IA/, out/HGAB-2027-VOL-IB/, at the PDF pages given in section 3.