Findings
Nine observations that the ledger supports on its face. None is a conclusion about wrongdoing:
the submission carries no approved budget for the contract,
procurement modality, or bidder count, so pricing and competition cannot be assessed from it alone.
F1
Spending trebled in the last four years without a stated capacity plan
FY2016–FY2022 averaged ₱211M a year. FY2023 jumped to
₱1.02B and FY2024 to ₱1.88B — 20 separate
contracts in FY2024, the most in any year. The four most recent years hold 70.3% of eleven years
of spending.
The step change is driven by two things at once: cloud subscriptions
(₱734.9M in FY2023, ₱809.4M in FY2024) and the
Subic build (₱697.9M). The list gives no indication that these were
sequenced against a single capacity plan.
F2
Colocation spending rose in the same years the government built its own data centers
DICT built NGDC3 (₱130.3M, FY2017), added electrical and backup power
(₱45.6M, FY2021) and developed the Subic site
(₱697.9M, FY2024). Over the same period, payments to lease space and racks
in other companies’ facilities climbed steadily: ₱28.7M (2018) → ₱177.3M (2021) →
₱192.0M (2023) → ₱362.3M (2024).
Building capacity did not reduce the rental bill in any year of the series. In FY2024, the year of
the largest single build, DICT simultaneously held four separate colocation contracts with four
different providers.
F3
Sixteen serial renewals of two colocation contracts, at a flat price
The Central Luzon and NCR2 colocation contracts with ePLDT, Inc. were each renewed eight times
between 2021 and 2022 — sixteen renewal instruments worth
₱386.0M, or ₱419.0M counting the two original
2020 contracts. Twelve of the sixteen renewals carry one of exactly two amounts:
₱21,900,000.00 (Central Luzon, six times) or ₱21,800,000.00 (NCR2, six times).
The cadence is exactly four renewals per site per year, in both 2021 and 2022 — consistent
with terms of roughly three months each. On that reading the Central Luzon requirement cost
₱87.6M a year by 2022, against ₱33.9M for the
original 2020 contract. The list states no contract term, so the comparison cannot be closed.
A first extension is ordinary. An eighth renewal at an unchanged price, with no rebidding visible
in the list, is the pattern that ought to draw attention — particularly where the incumbent
also holds cloud and managed-services contracts with the same department.
F4
One corporate group holds a quarter of the programme
33 suppliers appear in the list. The top five hold 54.7% of value; the top ten hold 82.4%.
Counting PLDT, Inc., ePLDT, Inc. and the Vitro / ePLDT joint venture together, the PLDT
group accounts for ₱1.21B across 24 contracts — 24.2% of the
eleven-year total, and the largest single relationship in the programme by a wide margin.
Radenta Technologies, Inc. appears in two separate joint ventures (with MaroonStudios and with
Crayon Software Experts) holding ₱520.4M combined.
F5
₱2.46B of cloud subscriptions bought through at least six different intermediaries
Cloud subscription and managed services are now the largest category at
₱2.46B (49.3%) across just 12 contracts. They are spread across
Amazon Web Services directly (₱186.8M), Google Cloud through
MaroonStudios JV Radenta (₱379.7M), “public multicloud” through
Crayon Software Experts in two lots (₱581.9M), private cloud through
Multi-Core JV CloudSigma (₱325.4M), the e-Government Cloud through ePLDT
(₱464.2M), and a data warehouse platform through MaroonStudios
(₱17.4M).
Five of the twelve, worth ₱1.23B, are described as maintaining an
existing environment. The list does not show how much committed capacity was actually
consumed under any of them.
How the ₱2.46B of cloud was actually contracted
All twelve cloud contracts, showing who was paid and whether the platform named in
the contract title is the party that received the money. The right-hand column reports only what
the contract titles state — corporate reseller relationships are not recorded in the source
document.
| FY | Entry | Contract | Contracting party (who is paid) |
Platform | Amount (₱) |
| 2016 | #1 | Design, build & operate a complete cloud solution | Vibal Group, Inc. + Philcox (Phils.), Inc. JV | no platform named | 372,579,426.00 |
| 2020 | #11 | Cloud hosting for government agencies and projects | Amazon Web Services, Inc. | contracting party is the platform | 21,257,711.17 |
| 2020 | #12 | Managed services, cloud environment of the Government Common Platform | Micro-D International, Inc. | no platform named | 109,470,500.00 |
| 2022 | #31 | Data warehouse platform cloud hosting | MaroonStudios, Inc. | no platform named | 17,380,000.00 |
| 2022 | #32 | Subscription & maintenance, existing cloud infrastructure (AWS) | Amazon Web Services, Inc. | contracting party is the platform | 165,528,752.85 |
| 2023 | #41 | Subscription & maintenance, existing Google Cloud infrastructure | MaroonStudios, Inc. JV Radenta Technologies, Inc. | platform named, contractor is not it | 152,948,980.87 |
| 2023 | #42 | Existing public multicloud infrastructure — Lot A | Crayon Software Experts Phils., Inc. JV Radenta Technologies, Inc. | no platform named | 367,478,048.71 |
| 2023 | #43 | Existing public multicloud infrastructure — Lot B | Crayon Software Experts Phils., Inc. | no platform named | 214,474,808.72 |
| 2024 | #51 | Existing private cloud environment of the government | Multi-Core Technology Resources Inc. JV with CLOUDSIGMA AG | platform inside the JV | 325,353,168.00 |
| 2024 | #54 | Managed services, the e-Government Cloud | ePLDT, Inc. | contractor’s own cloud | 464,188,000.00 |
| 2024 | #55 | Public cloud, pre-production environment | ePLDT, Inc. | contractor’s own cloud | 19,888,000.00 |
| 2025 | #65 | Subscription for the Google Cloud infrastructure | MaroonStudios, Inc. JV Radenta Technologies, Inc. | platform named, contractor is not it | 226,788,000.00 |
7.6%
Contracted directly with the platform owner — AWS, twice
₱186,786,464.02 · 2 contracts
92.4%
Contracted through a local company or joint venture
₱2,270,548,932.30 · 10 contracts
30.4%
Held by ventures including Radenta Technologies, across
two different JV partners
₱747,215,029.58 · 3 contracts
49.9%
Contracts maintaining an “existing” environment
₱1,225,783,759.15 · 5 contracts
Three things follow. Google Cloud was never contracted from Google — ₱379.7M across two
contracts, both through the same joint venture — while AWS, the only platform contracted
directly, is the smallest hyperscaler line. Both lots of the FY2023 multicloud procurement went
to the same principal company, Crayon, one with a JV partner and one without, totalling
₱582.0M; lotting normally exists to widen participation. And the reseller margin is invisible
throughout: with no ABC and no consumption figures, nothing shows what share of ₱2.27B was
platform capacity and what share was intermediary fee.
Note: “GCP” in entry 12 is the Government Common Platform, not Google Cloud
Platform.
F6
The single largest contract is the Subic build, at ₱697.9M
“Development of the DICT Subic Data Center Site Facilities and Integrated Network Security
Infrastructure” was awarded to DBP Data Center, Inc. in FY2024 — 14.0% of the entire
eleven-year programme in one contract, and the only entry of its size. Related Subic entries are
small by comparison: physical security (₱3.6M) and pest control and
disinfection (₱179.0K).
The list records no completion status, milestone schedule, or commissioning date for the facility.
F7
The list includes items that are not data center infrastructure
Five entries totalling ₱1.20M sit oddly in a data center project list:
office furniture for the DICT Central Office in two lots
(₱167,000 and ₱108,900), multifunction printer
inks (₱348,369), a hotel venue with meals for a stakeholders’ meeting
(₱400,000), and pest control (₱178,990).
The amounts are immaterial. What they raise is a scoping question: if furniture and printer ink
were counted as NGDC projects, the criteria used to assemble this list are not obvious, and it is
not possible to confirm from the document that the list is complete.
F8
The submission itself has gaps that block price verification
Entry no. 70 does not exist — the numbering runs 69, then 71. The last three entries carry no
Project ID at all. Project IDs are not chronological (ID 1352 is dated 2023 while 1353 and 1354 are
dated 2022), and one is formatted differently (1553-C).
More consequentially, the list has no column for approved budget for the contract, procurement
modality, award date, contract duration, number of bidders, or delivery status. Without the first
two, no judgement about whether any of these ₱4.98B in contracts was competitively priced can be
made from this document.
F9
Eleven years of data center spending, with no procurement of compute
Searching all 72 entries for servers, storage or compute returns nothing. This is the complete
list of entries that touch hardware in any form:
| FY | Entry | What it bought | Amount (₱) |
| 2017 | #4 |
Oracle — support services on software and hardware products |
34,928,030.94 |
| 2019 | #9 |
Oracle — extension of the same support | 4,324,172.80 |
| 2022 | #30 |
Anti-DDoS protection license | 15,497,000.00 |
| 2024 | #57 |
Network appliances, GDC1 upgrade | 1,463,100.00 |
| 2024 | #59 |
Desktop computers — monitoring workstations for GDC1 and GDC3 |
819,000.00 |
₱57.0M, or 1.1% of the programme — and the only actual machines in
it are desktops for staff to watch the data centers with. Every large line in this list is either
a place to put machines (₱888M of buildings and power) or someone else’s machines
(₱2.46B of cloud). Nothing in between.
That leaves a contradiction. Colocation is worth buying only if you own hardware that needs
housing — nobody rents racks to hold a cloud subscription. So ₱1.29B
of leased rack space implies a substantial government-owned estate that this list never shows being
bought. And if the answer is that workloads moved to cloud, colocation should be shrinking; instead
it went from ₱192.0M (FY2023) to ₱362.3M (FY2024). Even
“Government Data Center 2” turns out to be leased space, across four contracts with two
providers.
The likeliest explanation is scope rather than absence: the original compute was probably procured
before FY2016, under the predecessor ICT office, and simply falls outside this submission. The 2017
Oracle contract supports that — no agency pays ₱34.9M to support hardware it does not already
own. But that reading raises its own problem, because enterprise hardware runs five to seven years
and no refresh appears anywhere in this list. Either it was procured outside this
submission, or it has not happened.
The same gap applies to the FY2024 Subic build. ₱697.9M developed the
site; no compute was procured to fill it. A facility with power and cooling and no servers is a
shell, so the cost of making Subic operational is still ahead — which bears directly on the
budget now before the Committee.