Defense's endless objections and delays expose weakness of Duterte's case — prosecution's evidence stands unshaken
Deputy Minority Leader and ACT Teachers Party-list Representative Antonio Tinio slammed the defense strategy in Day 2 of the impeachment trial, noting that relentless procedural objections and delaying tactics reveal the weakness of Vice President Sara Duterte’s position and her unwillingness to seriously engage the accountability process.
“Puro drama pa rin si Duterte at hindi sineseryoso ang impeachment trial,” Tinio said, referring to the Vice President’s one-liner statement—“In this bloodbath and bludgeoning, I will be bloodied but unbowed”—delivered to media as she conferred with lawyers at the Senate. “Ang statement niya ay puro drama. Hindi nag-address sa kahit anong alegasyon. Hindi nito ipinakita ang kahandaan niyang harapin ang trial nang personal.”
Tinio noted that Duterte has yet to appear in person to defend herself against the charges, relying instead on her legal team to obstruct the proceedings.
“Walang katapusang objection sa lahat ng bagay,” Tinio said of the defense strategy. “Kung hindi objections, delaying tactics. Ang depensa ay gusto pang ipakita ang buong 2-oras na video ng press conference ng VP—na magpapahaba lang ng trial at magpapakita ng kahinaan ng kanilang posisyon.”
Tinio stressed that the defense’s primary strategy is to prevent evidence from reaching the public and the Senate through technical obstruction, a tactic that inadvertently exposes the gravity of Duterte’s violations.
“Ang strategy ng depensa ay iwasan o pigilan ang presentation ng ebidensya gamit ang mga teknikalidad,” Tinio said. “Ito ay nagpapakita na takot sila na malantad ang mga paglabag ni Duterte sa publiko. Kung walang kasalanan, bakit kailangan pang harangin ang ebidensya?“he said
Tinio pointed out that the evidence presented by the prosecution—videos of Duterte’s press conferences containing death threats—constitutes public knowledge that has already been witnessed by millions of Filipinos. The significance lies in formalizing this evidence within the impeachment trial as grounds for removal.
“Napanood na ng madla ang mga press conference ni Duterte kung saan nagbitaw sya ng mga banta,” Tinio said. “Ang kaibihan ngayon ay itinuturing nang ebidensya ang mga videos sa isang impeachment trial. Ito ang isang magiging batayan para matanggal sa pwesto si Duterte. Kaya natatakot ang depensa na ipakita ito sa opisyal na proseso.”
Tinio commended the prosecution for standing firm against the defense’s objections and the presiding officer for overruling motions that would have obstructed the trial.
“Ang prosecution ay malinaw na inilatag ang kaso,” Tinio said. “Ang NBI witness at video evidence ay nagpakita ng seryoso at dokumentadong nature ng mga banta na inilabas ng Vice President. Ang depensa ay walang sagot kundi objections.”
Tinio called on the Senate to remain vigilant as cross-examination of the NBI witness continues on Day 3.
“Dapat ipagpatuloy ang trial nang walang tigil at walang takot sa delaying tactics,” Tinio said. “Ang bayan ay naghihintay ng accountability. Hindi dapat payagan ang depensa na gawing drama ang prosesong ito,” ended Tinio.