DEATH THREATS BURIED UNDER LEGAL SMOKESCREENS; IMPEACHMENT COURT LOSES SIGHT OF REAL ISSUE
ACT Teachers Representative and Deputy Minority Leader Antonio Tinio condemned the deliberate obfuscation of the impeachment trial against Vice President Sara Duterte. The defense is using technical arguments to obscure a simple truth: we have video evidence of VP Duterte making death threats.
“The impeachment court must hear what is clear and straightforward,” Tinio declared. “There is video. There are death threats against President Marcos Jr., Liza Araneta, and Martin Romualdez. This is not a speech. This is not a political opinion. This is a crime—and it receives no protection under freedom of expression.”
According to the testimony of Atty. Lotoc, the NBI determined that Duterte’s statements constituted genuine death threats. Yet the defense refuses to engage with this reality. Instead, they are attacking the NBI investigation and claiming the agency is biased because it operates under the Department of Justice.
“This is simply a defense strategy: discredit the investigation, sow doubt, and leave the senator-judges without clear evidence,” Tinio observed. “But this should not work. Impeachment is not a criminal trial. The Senate does not need a conviction in regular court to declare a Vice President unfit for office—especially one who has uttered death threats against the President.”
Tinio also highlighted a critical deficiency in Duterte’s response to the impeachment complaint. “Duterte offers no specific denial. She does not say ‘I did not make those statements.’ Her answer is merely general denials. Such vague responses speak volumes—they are tantamount to an admission.”
The foundation of the entire case is straightforward: there is video evidence, there is an investigation, and there is an NBI determination that these are death threats. “This is all the senator-judges need,” Tinio explained. “There is no need for further debate about the credibility of the NBI or the origins of the investigation. The evidence is already here.”
The defense is using legal maneuvering to prolong the trial and distract from the fundamental question, Tinio charged.
“The question is simple: Is a Vice President who has uttered death threats against the President still fit for office?” Tinio said. “The senator-judges must answer this. They must decide now. The Filipino people are waiting for justice, not for more drama,”
Tinio called on the senator-judges to stop parsing technical arguments and focus on the facts.
“We have a video. We have an investigation. This is enough for the Senate to decide. Do not waste more of the people’s time and money on the defense’s games,” he concluded.