MAKABAYAN ON SC RULING ON POLITICAL DYNASTIES: WELCOME DECISION, BUT CONGRESS' LEGISLATION REMAINS NON-COMPLIANT
The Makabayan bloc welcomes the Supreme Court decision mandating Congress to enact the enabling law prohibiting political dynasties. The Filipino people now have an added legal weapon in their decades-long struggle to end the monopoly of a few families over political power. For nearly forty years, Congress has defied the clear constitutional command of Article II, Section 26 of the 1987 Constitution — that the State shall guarantee equal access to opportunities for public service and prohibit political dynasties. The Supreme Court has now affirmed what the people have long asserted: this duty is not optional, and inaction is unconstitutional.
We are, however, deeply alarmed by the legislation both in the Senate and in the House of Representatives that Pres. Marcos Jr. classified as priority legislation. What Congress as a whole is set to pass is not a law prohibiting political dynasties but a law legitimizing and regulating dynasties. It is precisely for this reason that we voted NO on the House of Representatives version. A measure that merely limits the number of family members who may simultaneously hold office does not dismantle dynastic rule — it institutionalizes it under a veneer of reform. Regulation is not prohibition, and no amount of legislative wordplay can make it so.
We therefore maintain that the current legislative actions are not compliant with the Supreme Court ruling. A genuine enabling law must prohibit dynasties outright, without loopholes that allow powerful families to rotate seats among relatives, hand off positions from one generation to the next, or carve up territories like family heirlooms. The Filipino people did not wait four decades for a law that formalizes the very evil the Constitution sought to eliminate.
We call on the Filipino people to struggle to dismanrle the political and economic basis of these political dynasties, to fight for genuine freedom and democracy.
We must mobilize on September 21 to assail the Marcos and Duterte political dynasties.