Tinio flags pork-type amendments approved by House subcommittee while state workers get zero
ACT Teachers Representative and Deputy Minority Leader Antonio Tinio raised the alarm over the Php 100.44 billion in pork-type amendments approved by the House Budget Amendments Review Subcommittee (BARSC) for the proposed 2027 national budget, even as government workers were denied a more substantial increase in their monthly allowance. He also called for the full disclosure of project lists, proponents, allocation criteria, and funding sources.
The Php 100.44 billion in pork-type amendments represents 86 percent of the Php 116.32 billion in total amendments approved by the BARSC on October 1 and 2. It went to 16 items vulnerable to legislative or executive discretion: the Assistance to Individuals in Crisis Situations (AICS), the Medical Assistance for Indigent and Financially Incapacitated Patients (MAIFIP), DPWH capital outlay, the Presidential Assistance to Farmers and Fisherfolk (PAFFF), TUPAD, the House of Representatives’ own budget, farm-to-market roads, the Local Government Support Fund (LGSF), the Tertiary Education Subsidy (TES), the Tulong Dunong Program, the Health Facilities Enhancement Program (HFEP), TESDA’s Training for Work Scholarship Program (TWSP) and Special Training for Employment Program (STEP), and three project lump sums: the National Irrigation Administration’s new locally funded projects sub-program, DOTr’s various locally funded projects, and Philippine Fisheries Development Authority fish ports.
“These amendments show that pork has not disappeared from the national budget. It has merely been repackaged under institutional amendments, local government support, infrastructure lump sums, and cash assistance programs,” Tinio said. “Pinalaki ang infrastructure pork at ayuda.”
“Meanwhile, no additional funds were provided for PERA (Personnel Economic Relief Allowance), despite the clamor to raise the current proposal of an additional Php 500 per month for government employees on top of the current Php 2000 to a more substantial amount. They have been waiting 17 years for a PERA increase. Neither were amendments provided for teacher pay or additional plantilla positions. DepEd’s Php 6.61-billion request for ARAL and learning recovery was not acted upon, while ARAL received only Php 350 million. These figures expose the distorted priorities of the amendments,” Tinio said.
He called on the House to reconsider. “Dapat dagdagan pa ang PERA ng mga kawani ng gubyerno.”
Seven of these programs—DPWH capital outlay, LGSF, farm-to-market roads, HFEP, MAIFIP, TUPAD, and AICS—received Php 77.86 billion of the amendments. Following the BARSC amendments, these seven will receive a combined Php 841.71 billion—equivalent to 49.7 percent of the government’s projected 2027 deficit. Their combined allocation increased by 12.5 percent from the 2027 National Expenditure Program, compared with only 2.1 percent growth over the 2026 enacted budget under the original proposal.
The LGSF received an additional Php 4.09 billion, raising its proposed allocation to Php 62.62 billion—its highest level ever. The BARSC also approved Php 11.49 billion in DPWH institutional amendments, Php 4.96 billion for farm-to-market roads, and Php 1 billion for a new NIA locally funded projects sub-program. Tinio noted that none of these were itemized.
He explained that several major amendments were presented without named projects or locations, including DPWH roads and convergence projects, farm-to-market roads, LGSF, NIA locally funded projects, DOTr locally funded projects, and locally funded projects of state universities and colleges and the National Housing Authority.
Tinio also questioned a proposed special provision allowing agencies to “modify” project details, including their location (station numbers and coordinates) after the budget’s enactment. “This already anticipates that a significant number of projects included in the amendments are not implementable as proposed. This is typical of congressional insertions where the necessary preparatory work has not been done.”
“Mapanganib ang malawak na kapangyarihang ‘mag-modify’ ng mga proyekto matapos maipasa ang badyet. Puwedeng magbago ang lokasyon, saklaw, o tunay na benepisyaryo. Kailangang limitahan ito sa pagwawasto ng malinaw na clerical errors, hindi sa paglilipat o pagpapalit ng mga proyekto,” he said.
Tinio said the pork-type amendments were approved amid a budget process that disclosed only one side of the ledger. While the BARSC identified Php 116.32 billion in additions, the hearing did not identify the specific items, agencies, or amounts that would be cut to fund them.
“No offsetting cuts were identified, and no grand total was announced. Sinasabi nilang kukunin ang pondo sa ‘slow-moving’ items at mababang utilization, pero walang tinukoy na ahensya, programa, o halaga. Kailangang ilabas ang buong listahan ng pinagkunan bago umusad ang panukalang badyet,” Tinio said.
He warned that undisclosed offsets could further reduce funding for essential public services, including education, health, and social protection.
“Hindi puwedeng dagdagan ang discretionary funds habang tinatapyasan o nilalagay sa alanganin ang mga serbisyong dapat direktang napapakinabangan ng mamamayan. The House must show both where the money is going and what programs will pay for it,” Tinio said.
Tinio emphasized that funds for personnel compensation, benefits, and new items should not be touched to fund the amendments. “Hindi dapat galawin laluna yung Php 55.8 billion Miscellaneous Personnel Benefits Fund, na laging tinatapyasan sa mga nakaraang budget.”
The BARSC amendments allocated Php 65.77 billion, or 56.5 percent of the total additions, to cash assistance programs such as AICS, MAIFIP, TUPAD, and the Presidential Assistance to Farmers and Fisherfolk. Hospitals, health facilities, and medicines received only Php 3.40 billion, while education and skills programs received Php 3.75 billion.
“Cash assistance cannot substitute for permanent and universal public services. Mahalaga ang ayuda pero kailangang pondohan ng sapat ang ospital, silid-aralan, guro, health worker para sa may kalidad ang serbisyo,” Tinio said.
He also criticized the Php 5-billion increase in the House of Representatives’ own budget, which would raise its allocation from Php 18 billion to Php 23 billion—more than twice the Php 1.95-billion increase for the Department of Education.
Tinio called on the House leadership to publish, before plenary approval, the complete list of offsets for the 116.32-billion amendments, as well as an itemized list of all the infrastructure projects that comprise the lumpsum amendments for the DPWH, DA, NIA, DOH, and other agencies, including the names of the individual proponents. “Dapat malaman kung alin ang binawasan para madagdagan ang mga nasa proposal. Para sa mga infrastructure projects, data din malinaw kung sino ang proponents, district representative man o pastelist, para may accountability.”
“Dapat maging bukas sa publiko ang buong budget trail—mula sa nagmungkahi, patungo sa pinondohan, hanggang sa aktuwal na gumastos. Kung walang transparency sa pinagmumulan at paggamit ng pondo, mananatiling itong pork barrel kahit palitan ang pangalan,” Tinio said.
“The plenary must reject amendments that expand discretionary and politicized funds. We should redirect public resources toward classrooms, hospitals, teachers, health workers, farmers, workers, and other essential services. Pangmatagalang trabaho, kabuhayan, at serbisyo, hindi pork para sa korapsyon at pansamantalang ayuda,” he ended.
Updated 5 October 2026: This release now counts the pork-type amendments across 16 items totaling Php 100.44 billion, or 86 percent of the total. The version issued on October 2 counted seven programs totaling Php 77.86 billion, or 67 percent. The figures for the seven programs’ combined allocation and share of the deficit are unchanged.