Back to List
Logo
media releases
2026-10-08

Tinio identifies sources of BARSC budget amendments: P116.32 billion in cuts from 21 agencies bankrolled 'pork' insertions

AT
Rep. Antonio Tinio
ACT Teachers Partylist

ACT Teachers Representative and Deputy Minority Leader Antonio Tinio today identified the exact sources of the P116.32 billion in cuts that bankrolled the pork-barrel amendments in HB 10858, the 2027 General Appropriations Bill (GAB), which the House voted to approve on second hearing yesterday.

Tinio pointed out that major increases in local infrastructure projects and ayuda programs were sourced from cuts to health, education, disaster relief, retirement benefits of government personnel, and foreign-projects. The House plenary adopted the amendments proposed by the House Budget Amendments Review Subcommittee (BARSc).

Tinio noted that the identification of increases and cuts made by the House in finalizing the House General Appropriations Bill had to be prepared by his own office, since the BARSc itself did not issue its own report. “I raised this as a point of order in plenary. The House is violating its own rules since the BARSc is required to issue a detailed report of amendments to the GAB, copies of which should be given to each House member and published to the House’s own website. Instead, we had to do our own analyis in order to understand what the House has done with the proposed budget for 2027.”

“The House bill keeps the same total amount of new appropriations proposed by the National Expenditure Program. This means every peso added by the BARSc was taken from somewhere else. The question is: why were public services and government workers’ retirement benefits sacrificed to make room for pork-type allocations?” Tinio said.

According to Tinio, the BARSC approved Php 116.32 billion in additions to 33 agencies. Of these, Php 100.44 billion, or 86.4 percent, could be characterized as pork-type items. These include Assistance to Individuals in Crisis Situations (AICS), the Medical Assistance for Indigent and Financially Incapacitated Patients (MAIFIP), various Department of Public Works and Highways programs, farm-to-market roads, the Presidential Assistance to Farmers and Fisherfolk Fund, TUPAD, the Local Government Support Fund, tertiary education scholarships, and the Php 5-billion increase in the House of Representatives’ own budget.

Based on the reconciliation of the BARSc amendments with House Bill 10858, the same amount was cut from 19 agencies and two lumpsum funds. (See provided table.) “The committee hearing showcased the additions, but did not disclose the cuts that financed them. Our analyis reveals that the House’s pork amendments are at the expense of funding for classrooms, vaccines, health facilities, disaster rehabilitation, irrigation projects, various big ticket foreign-assisted infrastructure projects, and retirement benefits,” Tinio said.

The cuts made by the House include the following:

1. The Department of Health received a gross BARSc addition of Php 28.36 billion, most of it for MAIFIP. However, other DOH programs were cut by Php 16.14 billion.

The Health Facilities Enhancement Program, to which the BARSC added Php 1.55 billion, ends up Php 4.45 billion below the NEP level, at Php 10.09 billion. The program funds the construction, upgrading and equipping of public health facilities.

The allocation for nationally procured commodities for family health, immunization, nutrition and responsible parenting was reduced from Php 9.10 billion to Php 4.23 billion. Health Promotion was cut by 81 percent, while the Quick Response Fund was reduced from Php 500 million to Php 100 million.

2. Despite a Php 1.95-billion BARSC addition to DepEd, the department’s allocation in the House bill is Php 6.17 billion lower than the NEP.

The Basic Education Facilities allocation ends up Php 3.10 billion below the NEP, even after the BARSC added Php 952 million for classrooms. The Computerization Program is cut by Php 3.16 billion, or 55 percent. The Project for Learning Upgrade Support and Decentralization and the Infrastructure for Safer and Resilient Schools programs were also reduced.

At the same time, the House bill contains a Php 1.93-billion increase in private-school voucher programs that was not part of the BARSC additions approved in the hearing.

3. The National Disaster Risk Reduction and Management Fund, or Calamity Fund, was cut by Php 9.5 billion. Disaster rehabilitation and reconstruction assistance to local government units fell from Php 14.67 billion to Php 6.92 billion—a more than 50-percent reduction.

The allocation for disaster risk reduction, mitigation, prevention and preparedness was also reduced by Php 1.75 billion. This amount was used to increase the DSWD Quick Response Fund from Php 1.25 billion to Php 3 billion.

4. The bill cuts Php 42.8 billion from four DOTr foreign-assisted projects:

- Php 19.7 billion from the Metro Manila Subway Project;

- Php 15 billion from the North-South Commuter Railway;

- Php 5.1 billion from the Davao Public Transport Modernization Project; and

- Php 3 billion from the New Cebu International Container Port.

Of the total, Php 35.1 billion comes from loan proceeds. The House bill does not explain whether the reductions will delay implementation, affect loan schedules or generate additional costs such as commitment fees.

The National Irrigation Administration also loses Php 5.28 billion from its NEP allocation. Five national irrigation projects lose a combined Php 1.95 billion, while six small reservoir projects lose Php 940 million, with projects in Libang River, Agusan del Sur, and Hibale, Bohol, dropped entirely.

5. The Pension and Gratuity Fund was reduced by Php 10 billion. The cuts affect terminal leave and retirement gratuity for both civilian personnel and military and uniformed personnel.

The bill leaves pension appropriations untouched but reduces the lump sums intended for workers who retire or leave government service in 2027. Civilian terminal leave was cut by Php 2.5 billion, while terminal leave and retirement gratuity for military and uniformed personnel were reduced by Php 4 billion and Php 3 billion, respectively.

Tinio decried the continuing lack of transparency in the House budget process despite the institutionalization of the BARSc. “Puro dagdag lang ang pinag-usapan sa BARSc at maging sa plenaryo. Dapat may malaya at bukas na diskusyon sa lahat ng amendments. Kinokondena natin ang naging lalong pagbawas ng pondo sa edukasyon, kalusugan, at iba pang serbisyo, at maging sa retirement benefits ng mga kawani ng gubyerno, para lalo pang dagdagan ang pork barrel at pang-ayuda ng mga kongresista.”

Tinio noted that the public should remain vigilant as the budget moves to the Senate and eventually the bicameral conference. “We continue to call for the removal of pork-type insertions, restoration of the cuts to essential services, restoration of funding for retirement benefits, and additional funding for compensation and benefits of government employees, particularly the increase of Personnel Economic Relief Allowance to Php 5,000 per month. The 2027 budget must be based on public need, not on legislators’ ability to control funds and distribute favors,” Tinio ended.